Skip to main content
Forge & Funnel

Paid Advertising

SEO vs Google Ads: where should a business invest first?

How SEO and Google Ads differ in speed, cost and risk, and how to decide which to start with for your situation.

Forge & Funnel · 27 January 2026 · 3 min read

Updated 20 October 2026

They solve different problems

Google Ads can buy eligible search placements while campaigns are running; paying does not guarantee enquiries. SEO aims to improve unpaid visibility, without a charge for each organic click, but content, technical work and maintenance still cost money. Neither channel guarantees a return.

So the real question is which problem you have now: a shortage of enquiries this quarter, or a reliance on paying for every visitor.

When Google Ads usually makes sense first

You need enquiries soon, for example a new business or a quiet period. You are testing whether a new service has demand before investing in pages for it. Your customers search with clear buying intent, such as 'emergency electrician near me'.

Campaign data may help identify useful searches if there is enough volume and reliable attribution. A short run with few enquiries is not enough to declare a channel successful or unsuccessful.

When SEO usually makes sense first

Clicks in your market are expensive and margins cannot absorb them. Customers research for weeks before choosing, reading guides and comparing firms. You already have a site with some visibility that is being held back by fixable problems.

In those cases the money that would go on clicks often does more when spent on better pages and technical fixes.

The trade-offs in plain terms

Ads can be launched once accounts, creative and tracking are ready, but spend continues while campaigns run. Landing pages and campaign learning can remain useful afterwards. SEO changes remain on the site, but visibility can change with competitors, demand and search systems. Compare platform spend, management, content, landing pages and tracking costs rather than treating organic visits as free.

Many businesses run a modest ads budget on their most valuable searches while SEO work builds up, then review the balance once organic enquiries are measurable.

Check the economics before choosing a channel

Estimate what remains from a completed job after its delivery costs, then consider how many qualified enquiries become paying customers. Multiply that contribution by the enquiry-to-customer proportion to estimate a ceiling for acquisition cost, before allowing for management fees and uncertainty. Revenue alone is not the amount you can afford to spend.

Hypothetical example: an emergency repair service with spare capacity may test tightly targeted ads, while a specialist consultancy with a long buying process may prioritise detailed service pages and search foundations. These are decision scenarios, not campaign results. Check actual demand, account eligibility, margins and follow-up capacity before spending.

Agree a test budget, what counts as a qualified enquiry and the conditions for pausing or reviewing. A phone-link click is not a completed call, and a form submission is not a sale. Without enough reliable data, report uncertainty rather than a precise return.

A check before spending on either

Open the page someone would land on and ask: is it obvious what you do, where you work and how to get in touch? Is there a phone number that works on mobile? Are form submissions and calls being recorded? If not, fix that first. Sending more visitors to a page that does not convert wastes money whichever channel brings them.

This article relates to our Paid Advertising work. See how we approach Paid Advertising.

Get a Free Website Review

We'll look at your website and marketing from the customer's perspective and tell you what we would change first.

Get a Free Website Review